Rant-023

 

PassageMaker - August 2002

 

Yacht Design is less Fine Art and more Performance Art... 

Actually Juggling comes to mind.

Designing a good boat requires more than simply aligning a variety of technical criteria till they form some text book cartoon of how a boat should look, be built or even perform. To be a good boat, you see, the boat must also be a good boat for someone. That is where the real challenge in design lies. Of course every owner (and every designer) wants a boat that is beautiful to behold, a capable performer, and perfectly safe. As the list of additional demands inevitably grows, however, all aspects of the boat become subject to compromise.

The best boat for speed would not be the best boat for comfort in a seaway, and neither would probably be the best boat for comfortable accommodations. The same could be said for hundreds of other features common aboard today’s cruising yachts. The skill resides in balancing all of these competing elements so that one does not inappropriately dominate. Sometimes cost or interior volume must suffer a bit for an owner who wants higher speed. The profile might get higher than you’d like to accommodate that six foot plus owner. Carrying huge interiors or huge fuel loads will cut into efficiency. But these are not so much shortcomings of the vessel as they are an indication of strengths that were considered most important to a given owner. Some folks drive sports cars. Some drive SUVs. Both can be great, just know the difference.

Every boat is a compromise: old bromide. Actually every element of boat design is a compromise. That’s okay. Don’t be too concerned about trade offs if the resulting boat does what you need it to do. Be more concerned if someone tells you they have a boat that does it all. Remember, even the best jugglers can only keep a limited number of balls in the air.

But then that’s just my opinion.

Copyright 2006

Charles Neville

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ó 2006, Charles Neville associates

223 Broadway

Centreville, MD 21617 - USA

Tel: 410 758-1891  -  Fax: 410 758-3724